Tesla ETFs Plunge as EV Funds Show Resilience Amid Stock Rout
Tesla’s sharp stock decline is hitting TSLA-focused ETFs hard, with year-to-date losses exceeding 40%. Meanwhile, diversified EV and Future Mobility ETFs are proving more resilient, highlighting shifting investor sentiment.
Tesla’s Decline Sparks ETF Turmoil
Tesla is facing an unprecedented consumer backlash in the U.S. and Europe, with JPMorgan warning it could be one of the most significant brand value declines in automotive history. Analyst Ryan Brinkman slashed Tesla’s Q1 delivery forecast to 355,000 vehicles (from 444,000) and cut its price target to $120 per share, citing CEO Elon Musk’s polarizing political alignment with President Trump and the far right in Europe as a key factor repelling buyers.
Brinkman also dismissed arguments that the Model Y changeover was to blame, instead pointing to data showing Tesla owners distancing themselves from the brand, even replacing Tesla logos with those of other automakers.
The backlash has hit Tesla’s stock, which fell 4% to $238 on Thursday, reflecting market concerns. Brinkman, a long-time Tesla bear, emphasized that the company faces significant risks from rising competition and potential loss of federal EV subsidies, which could slash earnings by 45%.
Despite Trump’s recent endorsement of Tesla, which briefly boosted interest, the long-term impact remains uncertain. Tesla’s challenges highlight the growing tension between its innovative technology and the political controversies surrounding its CEO.
ETF Market Reaction: Tesla-Centric Funds vs. Broader EV ETFs
Tesla’s stock (TSLA) continues to struggle, with a -4.83% weekly performance, -14.68% month-to-date, and a steep -38.10% year-to-date decline. This downturn has directly impacted Tesla-focused ETFs, with the Tesla Yield Shares Purpose ETF (YTSL) falling -6.88% weekly and -45.00% YTD, while the Harvest Tesla Enhanced High Income Shares ETF (TSLY) dropped -6.83% weekly and -44.97% YTD. These sharp declines underscore the significant risks tied to concentrated Tesla exposure.
In contrast, broader Future Mobility ETFs, which include Electric Vehicle (EV) and autonomous vehicle funds, have shown more resilience. The Evolve Automobile Innovation Index ETF (CARS) declined -3.89% weekly and -6.57% YTD, while the iShares Global Electric and Autonomous Vehicles Index ETF (XDRV) posted a milder -2.44% weekly drop but remains positive at +1.91% YTD.
This divergence highlights a shifting investor preference: while Tesla-focused ETFs are bearing the brunt of the company’s struggles, diversified EV and mobility funds are holding up better. The Future Mobility theme as a whole saw a -1.85% weekly decline and -4.84% YTD, outperforming Tesla-centric funds. This suggests that while sentiment around Tesla is deteriorating, broader confidence in the EV sector remains intact, favoring funds with diversified exposure over single-stock bets.
Group Data
Index Data
Funds Specific Data: YTSL, TSLY, CARS, XDRV, CARS.B, CARS.U
Please note this article is for information purposes only and does not in any way constitute investment advice. It is essential that you seek advice from a registered financial professional prior to making any investment decision.
