Mastering the Art of ETF Selection: A Guide for Canadian Investors
This guide aims to provide prospective ETF investors with clear guidelines on how to best screen, assess, and select ETFs.


Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) have become increasingly popular among Canadian investors in recent years due to their many advantages such as lower costs, diversification, and tax efficiency.
According to the Canadian ETF Association, assets under management (AUM) in the Canadian industry have grown to over $365 billion as of March 31st, 2023.
That being said this popularity has often come at the cost of "analysis paralysis" – the feeling of indecision faced by Canadian investors when confronted with an overwhelming choice of potential ETFs to invest in.
This guide aims to provide prospective ETF investors with clear guidelines on how to best screen, assess, and select ETFs, leveraging the industry-standard ETF Facts document.
Designed to provide a summary of key information prior to investing, the ETF Facts document is laid out in a transparent and simple format for ease of comparison. By understanding this document, Canadian investors can make more informed choices before buying an ETF.
Costs: Always Important
One of the most important factors to consider when selecting an ETF are the associated costs. All else being equal, higher fees directly eat into long-term expected returns, so it makes sense to keep them low wherever possible. An ETF's costs come from many different sources, all of which are important to understand:
- Brokerage commissions: When you buy and sell an ETF at a brokerage, you may have to pay a commission for the trade. This is dependent on the brokerage you use.
- Management Expense Ratio (MER): The MER of an ETF is comprised of the ETF's management fees and any administrative, operational, and marketing costs incurred by the ETF manager. It is expressed as a percentage fee deducted annually from the total value of your investment. For example, an MER of 0.10% would equal $10 for every $10,000 invested.
- Trading Expense Ratios (TER): Some ETFs incur extra trading costs. The TER is combined with the MER to form the ETF's overall expenses.
- Trailing commissions: Some ETFs may charge an ongoing commission for any services or advice an ETF sales representative or their firm provides to investors.
In the same way that returns compound over time, so do costs. Therefore, it's important to clearly understand how an ETF's costs are broken down, particularly in relation to comparable products.
Level of Assets under Management (AUM)
AUM is a key metric within the due diligence process, measuring the total market value of all the investments managed by an ETF.
AUM is important because, in addition to highlighting the fund’s size, it provides an indication of its overall popularity and stability. ETFs with high levels of assets under management tend to be more established, often with a solid track record and low risk of closure, whereas a fund with a low AUM may run a higher risk of being shut down and liquidated.
However, it is essential not to solely rely on AUM, as other factors such as trading activity, liquidity, and expense ratios should be considered.
Trading Activity and Liquidity
Understanding trading volume and liquidity is crucial when selecting an ETF. Trading volume refers to the number of shares traded during a specific period, while liquidity is the ease with which an asset can be bought or sold without affecting its price.
The trading volume for an ETF can be found in the ETF Facts document as "Average daily volume", expressed as a number of shares. You can also find the currency denomination the ETF trades under as well as the exchange(s) it is listed on.
Trading volume affects ETF liquidity but isn't the sole factor that determines how liquid an ETF is. Due to the creation/redemption mechanism of ETFs, the overall liquidity of the underlying asset is an equally important consideration.
In general, ETFs with high trading volumes and liquid underlying assets tend to incur lower bid-ask spreads, which is the difference between the price an investor can sell and buy an ETF at. This metric, expressed in percentages is labelled "average bid-ask spread".
The Underlying Index or Asset
The underlying index or asset is another critical factor to consider when selecting an ETF, as it plays a large role in determining the ETF's risk and return profile.
Indexes are rules-based methodologies for selecting and managing a portfolio of securities. There are different types of indexes on the market, such as market capitalization-weighted indexes, equal-weighted indexes, sector-specific indexes, and thematic indexes.
ETFs are highly flexible in terms of the range of asset classes they can track. In the Canadian market, ETFs can track equities, fixed-income, commodities, currencies, money market instruments, volatility derivatives, multi-asset, and even cryptocurrencies.
To evaluate the suitability of an ETF's underlying index or asset for their investment goals, investors can consider factors such as the index methodology, sector exposure, and historical performance against their risk tolerance, investment horizon, and investment objectives.
Again, the ETF Facts document can help with this assessment by providing a snapshot of an ETF’s top 10 individual holdings and corresponding percentage weights as of a particular date. It also shows the investment mix, which can be categorized by sector, geography, or asset class.
Finally, the section "What does the ETF invest in?" will usually describe an ETF's strategy. If the ETF is index-based, this will generally include the name and a brief explanation of the index the ETF is aiming to track.
Management Strategy: Active, Passive, or Smart Beta
Not all ETFs will track and replicate a benchmark index though. Some ETFs may be actively managed, which means that the ETF manager is actively selecting the underlying securities. This is often done with the goal of beating a benchmark or targeting another objective like increased income or hedging risk.
There is also a type of ETF that acts as a hybrid between passive indexing and active management known as a "smart beta" or "strategic beta" ETF. These funds employ rules-based screeners to select securities and are often based on "factors" that have historically produced better returns under specific market conditions.
Each strategy has its pros and cons. Passive ETFs tend to have lower expense ratios and are more tax-efficient, while active ETFs may provide the potential for outperformance through skilled management. Smart beta ETFs attempt to achieve better risk-adjusted returns than passive ETFs while maintaining lower costs than active ETFs.
As always, it’s a good idea to consider your investment objectives, risk tolerance, and preferences when choosing between these three ETF management strategies.
Tracking Error: Ensuring Your ETF Stays on Target
Tracking error is the difference between an ETF's performance and the performance of its underlying index. It is caused by many factors, which can include fees, trading costs, and ETF sampling strategies among others.
A lower tracking error indicates that the ETF closely tracks the performance of the index, while a higher tracking error suggests that the ETF deviates from the index's performance. Tracking error can be positive (the ETF beats its index) or negative (the ETF lags its index).
In general, a low tracking error is desirable as it signals that an ETF is well-managed and hugs its benchmark index close. Tracking error can impact an investor's returns, as a higher tracking error may result in underperformance compared to the index.
To assess an ETF's tracking error, investors can examine the ETF's historical performance against its benchmark index. For example, if an ETF has returned an annualized 10.5% over the last 10 years while its benchmark has returned 10.6%, the ETF's 10-year tracking error is 0.1%.
Practical Tips for Picking the Most Suitable ETFs for Your Portfolio
In addition to the factors mentioned above, investors should also consider the following three practical tips when selecting the best ETFs for their portfolios:
- Don't just rely on historical returns: The ETF Facts document provides a historical snapshot of the ETF's year-by-year returns, the best and worst 3-month returns over a 3-month period, and the average annual 10-year returns. Keep in mind that these metrics are backwards-looking and should not be relied upon to predict future returns.
- Understand how risk is measured: The ETF Facts document provides a visual gauge of the ETF's risk, on a five-level scale ranging from low to high. This risk gauge is based on the fund’s historical volatility, i.e., how much its returns have fluctuated year to year. It will not tell you how risky the ETF will be in the future, nor if the ETF is suitable for your personal risk tolerance.
- Assess diversification: Concentration, whether in terms of sector, asset, or geography can increase risk. It's a good idea to critically assess an ETF's investment mix and top 10 holdings to ask questions like:
- What percentage of the ETF's overall assets do the top 10 holdings comprise?
- Does the ETF invest in assets from more than one geography, and if so, what are the geographical weightings relative to each other?
- Is the ETF diversified across more than one sector, and if so, what are the sector weightings relative to each other?
- Is the ETF a multi-asset class ETF, and if so, what assets does it hold (stocks, bonds, commodities, alternatives) and in what proportions relative to each other?
- Does the ETF make use of exotic assets and strategies such as cryptocurrency, derivatives, short-selling, or leverage?
Conclusion
The growing popularity of ETFs has provided investors with a wide range of choices. With the insights and tips provided in this guide, investors can confidently navigate the world of ETFs and make the best decisions for their financial future.
Mastering the art of ETF selection involves considering various factors holistically. It's important to understand that there is no single metric that determines whether an ETF is good or bad, or its suitability for an investor.
By carefully assessing the considerations presented above in their entirety, Canadian investors can make informed decisions and build a well-balanced and diversified ETF portfolio that aligns with their investment goals and risk tolerance.
This article is sponsored by CIBC.






